Justice Katju and his Views on Subhas Bose and RabindraNath Tagore

M G Singh By M G Singh, 6th Jun 2015 | Follow this author | RSS Feed | Short URL http://nut.bz/2r7ul0pb/
Posted in Wikinut>Guides>History

Bose and Tagore are treated as holy cows in Bengal, but a closer look shows taht they had feet of clay.

Facts about some Holy Cows in India

These are the views of Justice Katju who was a distinguished judge of the Supreme Court and deserve to be read.
Are Tagore and 'Netaji' holy cows for Bengalis ?

One evening at Allahabad when I was a Judge there I was at the house of one of the High Court Judges along with some other Judges,chatting before dinner.

I mentioned my view about Subhas Chandra Bose, that he was a Japanese agent. At this one of the High Court Judges who was a Bengali reacted almost hysterically, and started shouting at me, and threatening to walk out. I was taken aback, and became mum thereafter, as I did not want the party to be broken up.

But I have witnessed a somewhat similar reaction by many ( not all ) Bengalis if one speaks against Tagore. It is sometimes impossible to talk rationally with many Bengalis about 'Netaji' and Tagore.
Are Subhas Chandra Bose and Tagore the private property of Bengalis ? Can no one criticize them in their presence ? If Bengalis regard them as public figures, not the private property of Bengalis, then the public surely has the right to assess and criticize them.
I have expressed my views about Bose and Tagore on my blog justicekatju.blogspot.in and I do not intend to repeat them in detail.

I regard Tagore as a British stooge who was promoted by Yeats and used by the British to divert literature from the revolutionary direction Sharad Chandra Chattopadhyaya was taking it ( see his novel ' Pather Dabi', which was banned by the British. At one time the price of one copy was the same as that of a Mauser pistol ).

See in this connection my article ' The Role of Art and Literature ' on my blog. I have explained there that there are broadly two theories of art and literature, one is called 'Art for art's sake', and the other is called ' Art for social purpose '. In a poor country like India only the second theory is acceptable. Tagore belonged broadly to the school of ' Art for Art's sake', propagating spiritualism and mystical nonsense ( see ( 'Gitanjali', 'Agni beena Bajao', etc ) and Sharad Chandra to the school of ' Art for social purpose'. The British were scared of the writings of Sharad Chandra, and so they promoted their stooge Tagore.

Am I not entitled to even present my view about Tagore before Bengalis ? Do I not have freedom of expression ?

I regard Bose as a Japanese agent, otherwise why did he give up the struggle against the British in 1945 when the Japanese surrendered ? If he was a real freedom fighter he should have carried on a guerilla war against the British, as the Chinese had done against the Japanese. In a guerilla war one fights with the weapons of the enemy, by snatching them from the enemy.

In fact Bose was only being used by the Japanese Imperialists, who would have bumped him off once his utility was over. Would the Japanese fascists have given freedom to India if they had defeated the British ? No, they would have looted it, and slaughtered a lot of Indians, the way they looted Manchuria and North China under their occupation, and slaughtered tens of thousands of Chinese in Nanking, Shanghai, etc. ( see on Youtube about these massacres ).

I have great respect for Bengalis, many of whom are my close friends. I would only request them to ponder about what I have said, and not treat Bose and Tagore like holy cows


Bose, British Raj, Gandhi, Japanese Army, Tagore

Meet the author

author avatar M G Singh
A man who spent his early years in Air Force. An avid writer with over 6000 articles and 60 short stories published.Two novels on the anvil for publication.

Share this page

moderator Mark Gordon Brown moderated this page.
If you have any complaints about this content, please let us know


author avatar Randhir Bechoo
6th Jun 2015 (#)

Interesting article.

Reply to this comment

author avatar M G Singh
7th Jun 2015 (#)

Thanks Randhir

Reply to this comment

author avatar pramalkumarsamanta
6th Jun 2015 (#)

Thanks for sharing a nice post. It is a fact that Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and Kabiguru Rabindra Nath Tagore were Indians. By virtue of their own merit they reached the pinnacle of fame, Kabiguru was the first Indian Nobel laureate In 1913 and Netaji was the greatest freedom fighter of Undivided India. They are not holy cows of Bengalis as stated but they are pride of Bengalis. There are eminent Bengalis like Raja Rammohan Roy, Swami Vivekananda, Rishi Sri Aurobinda Acharya Jagadish Chandra Bose,Dr Meghnad Saha,to name a few in pre -independent India.However I agree with his views about Kathashilpi Sarat chandra chattopadhyay, not Sharad Chandra. .

Reply to this comment

author avatar M G Singh
7th Jun 2015 (#)

Thanks for your views and correction

Reply to this comment

author avatar Sivaramakrishnan A
7th Jun 2015 (#)

Thought provoking Madan. I am always for frank discussion but emotions trump reason and logic often.

Regarding this issue, my knowledge is limited though I have met close associates of Netaji who are no more now. He did inspire them with his magnetic personality - siva

Reply to this comment

author avatar M G Singh
8th Jun 2015 (#)

Thank you Siva, but Justice Katju reasons he was a stooge of the Japanese

Reply to this comment

Add a comment
Can't login?